america, new york, noodle march, restaurants, reviews | No Comments | December 30th, 2009
Oh David Chang. How hyped up you’ve been. How polarising your food is. Inevitably, you either love your hate the brazen and sometimes winning concoctions that Momofuku restaurants serve up. The noodle bar is especially well known for a fresh approach to pan-Asian cooking, for amazing pork buns, and for a bowl of ramen you just have to try. Well, if it involves noodles, clearly I’m there. So, I marched down to 1st Ave the first time I was in New York City as an adult, patiently waited for the hot seat, and dove in. Now here’s where the yelpers declare war. Some claim the joint is well worth the big city prices, the big apple wait times, and the big names behind it, while others think it’s an over-priced, over-spiced, over-hyped trend.
And on which side of the line do I fall? Momofuku may be hit or miss, but for me it’s mostly miss. I’ve been a few times now, and as a Momfuku vet, I have to say the allure has rubbed off and in its stead lie over-salty noodles, over-sauced rice cakes, and not enough skill to back up the build up. Of course I still greatly enjoyed the experience, I was after all facing the prospect of a bowl of ramen, or ginger noodles, or spicy chow mein, or whatever was on the large chalkboard over the bar. Still, there are better noodles to be had faster and cheaper.
Perhaps my woes are the context. The ramen, so beloved by the write-ups, is crashing haute cuisine by the new “it” kid against the age-old fast food. The whole appeal of hot ramen is the efficiency, the standard-ness of it all, the mere fact that because you are only using two ingredients really, noodles and broth, they both better be damn good. There’s something about putting too-chewy noodles in searingly spice broth with a mucky egg and something more akin to cuban pulled pork that just rubs me the wrong way. Sure it’s got that cramped counter feel, that eat-it-and-run vibe, but the loving intensity of the chefs is not imbibed in every marble of fat that floats on the surface. So no, Momofuku, you ramen failed. But, if you stop thinking of the ramen as the crowning glory, in fact of the noodles being center stage at all, the place becomes infinitely more appealing. I was taken aback by how truly delectable all of the starters were, and again by how perfectly the seafood was paired with the accouterments. So perhaps, Momofuku, I failed you.
Don’t let me for one moment convince you any of the Momofuku establishments aren’t worth your patronage. The food is innovative certainly, and it’s rare someone takes on pan-Asian fusion wildly and aimlessly and comes out of it with accolades, but if you were ever to find an exception, New York would be the place, and David Chang would be your man. He ignores all the rules, and while a purist like myself can sometimes balk as Chang steamrolls the cultural nuances the average diner misses, he does add a good dose of open-mindedness to the American melting pot that can hardly be considered uncalled for. For all the food falls short, I’m still a fan.
The die-hard Daikokuya fan in me can’t concede the title of best ramen (tonkotsu is the real McCoy) to a contender as hodgepodge and poorly seasoned as Momofuku, I can say there are a few hits in the menu. For $35, the four-course pre-fixe is a steal, and every time I’ve gotten it at least one of the dishes has been stellar (last time was fennel and apple soup with rockpool oysters, the time before was seared skate medallion with pineapple salsa). The pork/shitake buns truly are some of the most unbelievable buns I’ve ever eaten: soft, moist, dripping with god knows what is in that sauce (probably baby tears, again, because something so delicious can only come from something so sacrilege). And of course, Texan as I am, any place you can get a Lone Star is okay with me.

My advice is to go, if nothing else to see what the fuss is about. Have yourself a soju slushie, sit at the open kitchen if you can, and at least consider the pre-fixe menu. Brave the line, definitely order the buns, and enjoy the ambiance, the experience, the wow factor that you can find only in New York, the kind of place that lets wacky experiments in multicultural inbred cuisine not just occur, but thrive. If all else fails, there’s always the soft serve for dessert. Don’t call it Milk Bar, just call it Plan B.
More pictures and videos of Momofuku and the rest of my trip to New York at Unlikely Squiggle’s Flickr.


















